The Beaver (2011)
Comments
bluegrasssoldier EricBuff Scott, I do not disagree with your definition of depression but the film still leaves some info out. If Walter was always this depressed why would Meredith had married him? Something has changed that has sent him to a darker place than he was once in. Was it medication, a death of a loved one or a gradual descent into madness? Clearly he is at an all time low. I just wanted to know if there was a reason.
ScottBuff There is no "reason" for depression. The only thing that has changed is the chemical balance in his brain.
EricBuff The reason is got worse? A greater chemical imbalance? That is a reason.
ScottBuff Is a cancerous tumor getting bigger, a reason for cancer?
EricBuff When Meredith fell in love and married Walter, he was not as depressed as he is when this film starts. So his depression got worse over time. Is that just how depression works or does something cause ones depression to become even more difficult to live with? This is a legitimate question.
ScottBuff It's irrelevant to this movie. Many things can impact depression, but they're things like diet, age, even amount of sunlight or exercise. But if you're looking for some Freudian emotional breakthrough moment where his character suddenly remembers some repressed childhood memory that explains it all and suddenly he's better, that just doesn't happen.
`Eric I could not relate to his character or his depression. Some exposition on it would have helped me to understand him better, no matter what the cause.
ScottBuff Well, that's a better way of saying it than just, "...we never discover why Walter was so depressed to begin with."
EricBuff In the words of a frustrated Peanuts character, "UGH!"
Barry I don't believe the thoughts on mental illness, depression are valid. Mania, and depressive behaviour are circular in most cases -- that means there are heightened episodes often followed by a more relaxed down time. In middle age and beyond this behaviour heightens. I don't know the film but everything in the synopsis makes medical sense. Just based on personal observations.
















Yes, very disappointing. I was really tired of Yelchin's character by the end. There needed to be less Yelchin and more Gibson. I felt like this film tried way too hard to be a family film which is why they put so much time into the teenage love side. Should have been darker, deeper and focused on adults.