← Back to the reviews

Black Swan (2010)

Comments (11)

  1. PatrickBuff

    I think this one will be a future classic that actually grows in stature over time. Possibly the most memorable movie of 2010. The only scene I didn't really like was the nightclub scene. It seemed out of character for Nina and is why I didn't give the movie 4 stars.

  2. ScottBuff

    The nightclub scene is crucial as part of showing her transformation into the Black Swan.

  3. PatrickBuff

    Good point but strictly from an entertainment standpoint it was the only time during the movie that I felt it dragged a bit.

  4. ScottBuff

    Only because you're gay. The other point of that scene is the build-up to the girl-on-girl action that was so obviously coming!

  5. PatrickBuff

    Guilty, just as the only reason you and Eric didn't like Now Voyager is because you are straight!!

  6. bluegrasssoldier

    I have really enjoyed Aronofsky films in the past. Requiem For A Dream being my favorite. But just as Erik points out, it seems Aronofsky's weak point is that he does not connect the audience with the character/s until the final scene. There are many solo scenes with Portman, but none that are personal until the very end. I know that she is supposed to be closed off to everyone, but without scenes that develop the character, I was not sure whose side to take. I don't want to be shown so much it makes the movie predictable, but a bit more direction was needed. In the last scenes we are shown where each character truly stands, I wish this had happened a bit earlier. Maybe a memory from the past that gives insight to the present. A scene or two away from Portman with one of the other characters. A scene with Cassel would have been great. She is supposed to be slipping into insanity as a mulit-personality disorder is taking grip on her, but in the last scene she seems to be fulfilled by her accomplishments and tranquil. She goes from being very insane capable of horrific acts to being something less disturbing. Reminds me of American Psycho. More splitting of the personality were needed, more of Black Swan and less White Swan. And just like American Psycho, I really don't see this being a classic.

  7. bluegrasssoldier

    I also did not like the casting of Winona Ryder. An unknown would have served better to the character. I was distracted by her filling the role. If not an unknown, someone who is more of a crazy bitch like Parker Posey perhaps.

  8. bluegrasssoldier

    I would say that I really liked the club scene. A person cannot watch a movie and know the experience of being intoxicated by a substance, but Aronofsky does a better job than any other director. This scene is bright, loud, skipping time, and hard to concentrate on. Portman's behavior is very believable. This is characteristic of the drug and others like it.

  9. EricBuff

    Her character may be on ecstasy but she is likewise crazy. Is her experience in the club due to drugs or insanity?

  10. bluegrasssoldier

    I posted the link to the documentary for purely educational purposes. I have read articles about the use of MDMA by psychiatrist to treat PTSD in soldiers, rape victims, ect. Pretty much anyone who cannot deal with an traumatic event in their life and so they suppress it to the point that it changes them completely. They usually have a very difficult time remembering the event at all. As the documentary stated, it was very effective when it was first used in conjunction with marital counseling where one or neither spouses would admit any fault. One woman in this documentary used it both as her husband was dying of cancer and after his death. The documentary also shows the reckless use and the dangerous outcomes from the drug. Even though it was filmed in 2000, it was very well done.

  11. bluegrasssoldier

    OH, and the experience in the club was all drug induced. The scene afterwards is not very accurate. She hallucinated that she was with Kunis. As much as the drug can make someone feel less inhibited and closer to others (strangers or family), and the drug will cause visuals, lights will stream as they move and spacial reasoning is also affected, but outright hallucinations are not characteristic.

Leave a comment

Your email is required but stays private: it’s never shown on the site and never shared or sold. Only the buffs can see it, and we’ll only use it if we want to reply to you directly about your comment.

8,683Reviews
3,766Movies
269Articles
2000Reviewing since