← Back to the reviews

Star Trek (2009)

Comments (10)

  1. EricBuff

    Scott, after reading all of your negative reviews of the Next Generation Star Trek movies, I wonder why you did not better embrace this entertaining effort?

  2. EricBuff

    Why did you not like this movie, if the previous Star Trek films were no better?

  3. ScottBuff

    2,3,4,6 and 8 were as good or better and all of them were fairly consistent and none of them told me that everything from the past 50 years was no longer true.

  4. EricBuff

    Your reviews of the other Star Trek movies seem to imply that they were out of good ideas, so why not start over?

  5. ScottBuff

    I have no problem with them starting over. But why purposefully set it in the same universe as the old movies and say, none of that happened. Either stick with the old universe as canon or never even mention it again.

  6. bluegrasssoldier

    I have to agree with Scott. How are sequels to this movie supposed to be done? Are all the events that happened in the previous movies supposed to be erased? This approach to reinvent the saga is a little much.

  7. EricBuff

    I disagree. The franchise needed to be made fresh.

  8. PatrickBuff

    Eric, I'm on your side on this one.

  9. PatrickBuff

    Scott, this movie doesn't say that none of the original stuff ever happened. It happened that way the first time and then Spock went back and changed things. It is the same conundrum that exists in all time travel movies.

  10. ScottBuff

    I still say they should have just started fresh and ignored the previous films if they wanted to reboot the franchise. Trying to combine this with the original does neither version any favors.

Leave a comment

Your email is required but stays private: it’s never shown on the site and never shared or sold. Only the buffs can see it, and we’ll only use it if we want to reply to you directly about your comment.

8,683Reviews
3,766Movies
269Articles
2000Reviewing since