← Back to the reviews

Brigadoon (1954)

Comments (11)

  1. ScottBuff

    Patrick, "I suppose Brigadoon could have been a great movie. If it was shot on location, had a different score and featured more dancing from the two leads." so basically it could have been a good movie if it was a completely different one.

  2. Barry Lane

    Brigadoon has its flaws, but not shooting on location may not be one of them. This is a fantasy about a man embracing death. I think Kelly sings, acts and dances well. Van Johnson was a chorus boy in Kelly's breakout stage performance, Pal Joey. They both did okay. I am a big Van Johnson fan. Cyd came to Toronto and did a play with and for me in 1985. A revival of The Pleasure Of His Company. She was a grand person.

  3. PatrickBuff

    Ha Ha Ha Scott, that is what I'm saying.

    Barry, I get what you are saying about the fantasy element but I think it worked better onstage than for the screen. Kelly sings fine and dances well, just not enough.

    Cyd Charisse was a truly glorious dancer. I'm jealous that you knew and worked with her!!

  4. Barry Lane

    About structuring in the musical theatre: Many of these big choral dance numbers have a dual purpose.To entertain in the classic Agnes DeMille sense, but also to give the leads a little time to change wardrobe, and the stage management team to implement extensive set changes and redecoration. In film these things are not necessary but are often hold overs. I thought the stuff without the stars over-done and over-long. Not strong enough either way. In thinking about Van's Bonnie Jean number--for me, highlight.

  5. EricBuff

    Scott, It is a fantasy about escaping the stress of life to an ideal place. Why don't you review Miracle on 34th Street and complain that Santa is not real?

  6. ScottBuff

    Eric, I don't understand your complaint

  7. EricBuff

    Of plot does not make sense, but it is not intended to.

  8. ScottBuff

    Simply because a movie contains fantastical elements doesn't excuse it from all forms of logic.

  9. EricBuff

    Yeah, it kind of does.

  10. ScottBuff

    I disagree.

  11. Julie

    I loved this film, I've watched it numerous times

Leave a comment

Your email is required but stays private: it’s never shown on the site and never shared or sold. Only the buffs can see it, and we’ll only use it if we want to reply to you directly about your comment.

8,683Reviews
3,766Movies
269Articles
2000Reviewing since