Brigadoon (1954)
Comments
ScottBuff Barry Lane Brigadoon has its flaws, but not shooting on location may not be one of them. This is a fantasy about a man embracing death. I think Kelly sings, acts and dances well. Van Johnson was a chorus boy in Kelly's breakout stage performance, Pal Joey. They both did okay. I am a big Van Johnson fan. Cyd came to Toronto and did a play with and for me in 1985. A revival of The Pleasure Of His Company. She was a grand person.
PatrickBuff Ha Ha Ha Scott, that is what I'm saying.
Barry, I get what you are saying about the fantasy element but I think it worked better onstage than for the screen. Kelly sings fine and dances well, just not enough.
Cyd Charisse was a truly glorious dancer. I'm jealous that you knew and worked with her!!
Barry Lane About structuring in the musical theatre: Many of these big choral dance numbers have a dual purpose.To entertain in the classic Agnes DeMille sense, but also to give the leads a little time to change wardrobe, and the stage management team to implement extensive set changes and redecoration. In film these things are not necessary but are often hold overs. I thought the stuff without the stars over-done and over-long. Not strong enough either way. In thinking about Van's Bonnie Jean number--for me, highlight.
EricBuff Scott, It is a fantasy about escaping the stress of life to an ideal place. Why don't you review Miracle on 34th Street and complain that Santa is not real?
ScottBuff Eric, I don't understand your complaint
EricBuff Of plot does not make sense, but it is not intended to.
ScottBuff Simply because a movie contains fantastical elements doesn't excuse it from all forms of logic.
EricBuff Yeah, it kind of does.
ScottBuff I disagree.
Julie I loved this film, I've watched it numerous times
















Patrick, "I suppose Brigadoon could have been a great movie. If it was shot on location, had a different score and featured more dancing from the two leads." so basically it could have been a good movie if it was a completely different one.