Fort Apache (1948)
Comments
EricBuff PatrickBuff She probably went to school on the Fox lot.
Barry Lane Ther is a lot to this picture. 1. Thursday is full of himself, but there are enormous differences between Philadelphia and Lt. O'Rourke: Class, background, religon. 2. Thursday, for all his shortcomings has his moments: The scale, his treatment of the GRant Withers character, his courage in battle. 3. John Wayne is the hero. Not the focal point of the story, it is an ensemble piece, but he is the audience identification character. The voice of reason. The guy we would all like to become.
Barry Lane Re religon: Bearing in mind this is 1870, the O'Rourke's are almost surely Irish Catholic, the Thursday's almost surely Episcopalian, or some other Protestant denomination. The schism was fairly wide.
PatrickBuff Barry, you are correct that religious differences would have been part of the reason Thursday was against his daughter marrying O'Rourke. It does not, however, excuse his rude manners. And I also agree that he was a man of principal but not a smart military tactician.
Barry Lane Of course not, Patrick. He is a terrible person, but makes the movie interesting. Yes? And based on results, a downright foo.
Barry Lane correction: ...fool.
PatrickBuff Agreed. And this is one of the rare movies where Henry Fonda plays the antagonist.
Dale Cox It is not a Western. It is no more Western than Sands of Iwo Jima, The Horse Soldiers, Major Dundee, or Saving Private Ryan.
Rosie Powell I had no problems with Shirley Temple in this movie. She was her usual competent self. I wish I could say the same for John Agar, but he didn't really impress me. John Wayne gave a good, solid performance. But in my opinion, the film belonged to Henry Fonda. I think he gave one of the best performances of his career.
















Her lack of education? I wonder if she went to school or had a studio tutor?