Leatherheads (2008)
Comments
Barry PatrickBuff Barry, You can dislike Clooney all you want but that doesn't change the fact that at no point in this movie does he insult servicemen.
Barry Lane I've the Blu Ray here and in the next several days run it again -- and respond, even revise my original take.
PatrickBuff Cool, I look forward to reading what you have to say.
Barry All right, Patrick. I stand corrected. Clooney is particularly against the military, he is against everything that is American tradition. Apparently he has seen a lot of movies, and must not have liked them. Somewhere between Gable/Loy romantic comedies and the keystone cops he has esthetically and commercially missed the boat. And I mean that for the direction. As an actor, he and his other cast mates do just fine when given any kind of opportunity. The film is beautiful to look at and the score, while neither original or memorable, is still appropriate. But he packing, the cutting the smug and superior attitude throughout just stinks. No one will tell him. Smokehouse/Clooney will believe that you can't make a football picture set in the past, when the truth is, he can't. All of this goes to vision and vision comes from the soul. What one believes, or does not. And, that is the political component at it worst.
Barry should read 'not' particularly ...
Barry And ...' the pacing...not he packing...
PatrickBuff Barry, You are free to interpret Clooney's motivations as you see fit but it comes across as a projection of what you assume a liberal thinks and feels. I do agree with you that the movie isn't very good but I don't think it has anything to do with his politics.
Barry Patrick, replace politics with point of view. Anyone who does a keystone cop routine -- without laughs -- surely doesn't understand the genesis, the psychology or the sociology required. Not to mention the film making taste. If that isn't political then Len Riefenstahl has no place in the firmament. Of course, what you bring to t he table as a person is political. Just look at the way John Ford and Howard Hawks handled their representations of life in the past. Also, political, and sometimes quite critical, but filled with film sense and love.
PatrickBuff Barry, I don't think it's as complicated as all that. You just need a creative mind an eye for the visual and impeccable comic timing to make a great Keystone Cop routine.
Barry Lane The keystone routine was just the easiest and most obvious soulless failure.
PatrickBuff Barry, we'll have to agree to disagree on this one. In my opinion this movie doesn't reflect Clooney's politics nearly as much as you say. If you didn't know who directed it you would have a different view.
Barry Lane Patrick, yes. But, I would still have been more than disappointed. It stinks. No fun.
















I am with Eric. I personally dislike George Clooney, but wish I did not. He is as close to an old time movie star as we have. Really, too bad.