← Back to the reviews

Min and Bill (1930)

Comments (5)

  1. Movie fan

    If you don't know what you're talking about, you should do your homework. Marjorie Rambeau was a beauty on stage for years, and her contemporary Mae West probably caught HER act and borrowed from her. People like you, who really don't like old movies in the first place, shouldn't impose your judgements on the rest of us. I admit I don't like movies that are made now, but the difference is I don't offer my opinions on them.

  2. ScottBuff

    "Movie fan", it's you who should do your homework. If you spent any amount of time on this site at all you would realize that no one in the entire history of the world is a bigger fan of old movies than Patrick. I would put his knowledge of them against anyone. The very idea that someone would say, "who really don't like old movies in the first place" in regards to him is such an insanely stupid comment that it's laughable.

  3. PatrickBuff

    Thanks Scott. Yes, "Movie fan" I do love old movies. But I will admit that I knew little about Marjorie Rambeau's stage career. I stand corrected that she may well have influenced Mae West's style.

  4. EricBuff

    Scott, I would like to argue your lack of appreciation for MIn and Bill but I cannot remember enough of it to do so. I guess that helps your argument.

  5. PatrickBuff

    This movie was so popular that Dressler was ranked as the top box office attraction in 1931.

Leave a comment

Your email is required but stays private: it’s never shown on the site and never shared or sold. Only the buffs can see it, and we’ll only use it if we want to reply to you directly about your comment.

8,683Reviews
3,766Movies
269Articles
2000Reviewing since